You audit your suppliers’ controls. Who looks at their culture?
November 17, 2026

Certificates, questionnaires and assurance reports tell you about a supplier's controls. They cannot show whether its people will raise a problem early, and that matters most when something goes wrong.
Every year, suppliers to UK financial firms send the same kinds of evidence. Completed questionnaires. Assurance reports from their auditors. Certificates against recognised security standards.
That evidence is useful, and firms need it. It is also limited. Each document describes controls, within a set scope, over a set period. Most are commissioned or completed by the supplier itself. They say little about what the supplier's people will do at 2am when something starts to go wrong or how they will go about informing you of a complex issue.
UK rules already expect firms to understand the suppliers behind their important business services. Yet the FCA's March 2026 review of resilience self-assessments found "more work to do on identifying, assessing and remediating third party vulnerabilities".
The same review made a point about clean results. Where a firm reports few or no outstanding vulnerabilities but gives little evidence on mapping and testing, checking is hard. In the FCA's words, "it makes it difficult to check whether they've identified vulnerabilities properly". A clean supplier report deserves the same question. Clean compared with what, and checked by whom?
Start with scope. Check that the report covers the service you actually buy, from the entity and location that actually deliver it, for the period you rely on.
When something goes wrong at a supplier, capacity and controls matter. So do three things no certificate shows. Whether its people raise the problem early. Whether its risk and security teams are heard inside their own business. And what its incentives reward when the news is bad.
The same habits are likely to travel down the chain, because how a supplier chooses and watches its subcontractors tends to reflect its culture.
The regulators are starting to ask for this kind of behaviour across the boundary. The critical third party regime aims to promote "stronger communication", including through "joint testing exercises".
Most of your suppliers are not banks. In a July 2026 blog, the FCA and PRA described the third parties that banks, insurers and payment firms increasingly rely on. They "may be cloud providers, technology firms, data providers or other specialist service providers".
That matters for how you judge them. A cloud provider, a pensions administrator and a facilities firm work in different worlds. A culture yardstick has to make sense to all of them, and to you.
This is where we think risk culture measurement can add something new to third party risk.
Our Risk Culture Index is built on a model developed from the experience of risk professionals across a range of industries, not banking alone. That breadth matters here, because the people you need to understand at a key supplier may work in technology, operations or facilities, not finance.
It covers familiar ground, such as leadership, accountability and incentives. It also covers less familiar ground, such as the role of middle managers.
The index compares how leaders, employees and risk professionals see risk being understood, owned and acted on. Where those views differ, there is usually something worth knowing.
We believe the same approach could build real insight into your most important supplier relationships. With the supplier's agreement, we could run the Risk Culture Index with the teams on both sides. That would mean the people at your firm who manage the relationship, and the people at the supplier who deliver the service.
Compare how leaders, staff and risk professionals on each side see the same relationship. Where they agree, you have a shared starting point. Where they differ, you have found where to look first.
Measured at the start and again later, it could show both sides whether the relationship is getting stronger. It wouldn't replace due diligence. It would add what due diligence struggles to see.
The point is not to grade the supplier. It is to give both organisations a shared, evidence-based view of how each side sees risk being handled, and where it could break. Suppliers have a reason to take part, too. It gives them evidence from their own people at every level, which is different from a questionnaire one team completes.
Look for these signals in your next review, exercise or incident:
A certificate tells you what a supplier has built. Its culture tells you what will happen when that breaks.
Dr Jon Baker is a Principal Consultant at Contexis. This is one of four Contexis articles on culture in third party risk. Our Risk Culture Index looks at how risk is understood, owned and acted on, and is built on the Pan-Industry Risk Culture model. Find out more about our risk and control work here.Â
Every year, suppliers to UK financial firms send the same kinds of evidence. Completed questionnaires. Assurance reports from their auditors. Certificates against recognised security standards.
That evidence is useful, and firms need it. It is also limited. Each document describes controls, within a set scope, over a set period. Most are commissioned or completed by the supplier itself. They say little about what the supplier's people will do at 2am when something starts to go wrong or how they will go about informing you of a complex issue.
UK rules already expect firms to understand the suppliers behind their important business services. Yet the FCA's March 2026 review of resilience self-assessments found "more work to do on identifying, assessing and remediating third party vulnerabilities".
The same review made a point about clean results. Where a firm reports few or no outstanding vulnerabilities but gives little evidence on mapping and testing, checking is hard. In the FCA's words, "it makes it difficult to check whether they've identified vulnerabilities properly". A clean supplier report deserves the same question. Clean compared with what, and checked by whom?
Start with scope. Check that the report covers the service you actually buy, from the entity and location that actually deliver it, for the period you rely on.
Behaviour decides what happens next
When something goes wrong at a supplier, capacity and controls matter. So do three things no certificate shows. Whether its people raise the problem early. Whether its risk and security teams are heard inside their own business. And what its incentives reward when the news is bad.
The same habits are likely to travel down the chain, because how a supplier chooses and watches its subcontractors tends to reflect its culture.
The regulators are starting to ask for this kind of behaviour across the boundary. The critical third party regime aims to promote "stronger communication", including through "joint testing exercises".
Most of your suppliers are not banks. In a July 2026 blog, the FCA and PRA described the third parties that banks, insurers and payment firms increasingly rely on. They "may be cloud providers, technology firms, data providers or other specialist service providers".
That matters for how you judge them. A cloud provider, a pensions administrator and a facilities firm work in different worlds. A culture yardstick has to make sense to all of them, and to you.
A culture lens has to work outside banking
This is where we think risk culture measurement can add something new to third party risk.
Our Risk Culture Index is built on a model developed from the experience of risk professionals across a range of industries, not banking alone. That breadth matters here, because the people you need to understand at a key supplier may work in technology, operations or facilities, not finance.
It covers familiar ground, such as leadership, accountability and incentives. It also covers less familiar ground, such as the role of middle managers.
The index compares how leaders, employees and risk professionals see risk being understood, owned and acted on. Where those views differ, there is usually something worth knowing.
The same lens could work across a supplier relationship
We believe the same approach could build real insight into your most important supplier relationships. With the supplier's agreement, we could run the Risk Culture Index with the teams on both sides. That would mean the people at your firm who manage the relationship, and the people at the supplier who deliver the service.
Compare how leaders, staff and risk professionals on each side see the same relationship. Where they agree, you have a shared starting point. Where they differ, you have found where to look first.
Measured at the start and again later, it could show both sides whether the relationship is getting stronger. It wouldn't replace due diligence. It would add what due diligence struggles to see.
The point is not to grade the supplier. It is to give both organisations a shared, evidence-based view of how each side sees risk being handled, and where it could break. Suppliers have a reason to take part, too. It gives them evidence from their own people at every level, which is different from a questionnaire one team completes.
You can start without a survey
Look for these signals in your next review, exercise or incident:
- How bad news arrives: who calls, how quickly, and how complete is the first message?
- Who joins the call: is it the account manager, or the people who actually run the service?
- Whether their risk people speak: in joint meetings, are the supplier's risk and security staff heard, or spoken for?
- What happens to near misses: does the supplier tell you about problems it caught in time?
- Whether the story changes: do the answers shift when the commercial lead leaves the room?
A certificate tells you what a supplier has built. Its culture tells you what will happen when that breaks.
Dr Jon Baker is a Principal Consultant at Contexis. This is one of four Contexis articles on culture in third party risk. Our Risk Culture Index looks at how risk is understood, owned and acted on, and is built on the Pan-Industry Risk Culture model. Find out more about our risk and control work here.Â
Related articles
Read
Humanising business – the new organisational imperative
22.05.2023
The role of business in society has changed. Profit alone is no longer enough. John Rosling explores why human-centred, purpose-led organisations build trust, wellbeing and better performance. But what does humanising business actually mean?
Read article
Read
How can you manage corporate risk through culture?
10.09.2024
Managing corporate risk is usually about processes and oversight to predict and avoid human error. But we all know it’s people that cause problems, and who will save you from them if they care enough. As Warren Buffett says “culture, more than rule books determine...
Read article
Read
Face the future with a lot more humility
05.12.2023
Purpose leads to higher engagement and profitability. But you cannot show whether your purpose is working if you cannot measure it and ESG does not measure purpose. We want to prove it's happening and the Contexis Index gives us a measure of where we go next.
Read article