Why saying you could recover from anything is a warning sign

November 04, 2026
Why saying you could recover from anything is a warning sign
Some firms' self-assessments say there is no scenario they could not recover from. Curiosity, the habit of asking what could break and then testing it, is how you find out whether that confidence is well placed.

It is one of the more striking lines in the FCA's March 2026 review of operational resilience self-assessments. "Some firms state in self-assessments that there's no scenario that they wouldn't be able to recover from," the FCA wrote. Its concern was evidence. Those firms had not shown that they had tested this against severe enough scenarios.

The same review recognised how hard recovery can be. Many firms, it said, "would find it a complex challenge to remain within impact tolerance" in some scenarios. It pointed in particular to "a severe cyber attack or significant outage at a third-party provider".

So the regulator thinks recovering from a supplier failure is hard, and some firms think nothing is beyond them. What closes the gap between those two views is a severe test, run and written down.

Every scenario test starts with a good question


Curiosity rarely appears in a risk framework. We think it should. Every scenario test, exit plan and service map starts with someone asking an uncomfortable question. What happens if our cloud provider goes down? How would we cope with ransomware at a key supplier? What's the worst that could happen, and have we ever tried it?

In our view, firms that ask those questions find their weak points on their own terms. Firms that never ask tend to find them during an incident, in front of customers.

In the FCA's description of good practice, firms "have considered alternative ways to recover from cyber attacks, third-party failures, and other operational outages". That only happens when someone has asked.

We read the FCA's review as showing where curiosity tends to stop. Mapping, it said, "has been largely focused on technology". It wants firms to cover facilities, people, processes and information as well. A supplier can fail you through any of them, not only through its systems.

Someone watching your provider is not a complete answer


Since 13 July 2026, the Bank of England, the PRA and the FCA have overseen four cloud providers designated as critical third parties. They are Amazon Web Services, Google Cloud, Microsoft and Oracle. That oversight covers the services they provide to UK financial firms.

It would be easy to feel safer. The regulators have been careful to say otherwise. The regime "complements, but does not replace" the rules firms already follow. Firms remain responsible for their own third party arrangements, including contingency planning.

A regulator overseeing your cloud provider watches the resilience of its services to UK finance, not your ability to serve customers when they fail.

The question is a live one. In October 2025, a fault in one Amazon Web Services region in the United States disrupted services around the world for much of a day. UK bank customers and HMRC's online services were among those reported as affected.

The sector has now rehearsed this question. On 8 October 2026, the Cross-Market Operational Resilience Group completed SIMEX26, a sector-wide exercise. Its scenario was "a global cloud services disruption".

The 38 largest and most systemically important banks and market infrastructure operators took part. The Bank of England now expects firms "to take action based on the exercise". If yours was not among the 38, the exercise has not answered the question for you. Your own test still has to.

Curiosity has limits


Curiosity has limits, and it helps to be honest about them. It won't change the fact that a handful of providers provide much of the sector's cloud services. That is market structure, and it is part of why the regulators now oversee those providers' services to UK finance. Nor will curiosity stop a zero-day attack, or a coding error inside a supplier that no amount of planning at your firm could have prevented.

What curiosity changes is what you know before the day it matters. You can't choose whether a major provider fails. You can choose whether you have already tested what you would do and your teams are ready to respond.

One test tells you more than the paperwork will


Ask these about each of your most important suppliers:

  • If this supplier stopped today, which of your key services would stop, and for how long could you cope?

  • What would you do in the first hour, the first day, and who would decide?

  • If this supplier went for good, what would replace it, and how fast?

  • When did you last test any of that with the supplier in the room?


Then run one exercise with your most important supplier, even if it is only a tabletop discussion of a single bad day. Keep it simple: a scenario, a clock, and the people who would really be on the call. If you have an exit plan, measure how long it would take and what it would cost, not just whether it exists.

This is less common than it should be. Even among organisations that rate their own cyber resilience as high, only 44% simulate cyber incidents or plan recovery exercises with ecosystem partners. Among those that see themselves as insufficiently resilient, the figure is 16%. The figures come from the World Economic Forum's Global Cybersecurity Outlook 2026, and HM Treasury cited the 44% figure in July 2026. They cover all sectors, not only finance.

The question was never whether you could recover from anything. It's which things you have actually tried and experienced.  Being curious, trying to work out how things break builds a culture which will respond more quickly and more effectively if the worst happens. 

 

Dr Jon Baker is a Principal Consultant at Contexis. This is one of four Contexis articles on culture in third party risk. Our Risk Culture Index looks at how risk is understood, owned and acted on, and is built on the Pan-Industry Risk Culture model. Find out more about our risk and control work here.
Related articles
Read
Humanising business – the new organisational imperative
22.05.2023
The role of business in society has changed. Profit alone is no longer enough. John Rosling explores why human-centred, purpose-led organisations build trust, wellbeing and better performance. But what does humanising business actually mean?
Read article
Read
How can you manage corporate risk through culture?
10.09.2024
Managing corporate risk is usually about processes and oversight to predict and avoid human error. But we all know it’s people that cause problems, and who will save you from them if they care enough. As Warren Buffett says “culture, more than rule books determine...
Read article
Read
Face the future with a lot more humility
05.12.2023
Purpose leads to higher engagement and profitability. But you cannot show whether your purpose is working if you cannot measure it and ESG does not measure purpose. We want to prove it's happening and the Contexis Index gives us a measure of where we go next.
Read article